Colleen (Nicole Vaunt) is carrying her groceries home, and her bags are so full that she accidentally spills them. She manages to grab one item with her teeth to prevent it from hitting the ground, but suddenly her attractive new neighbor, Heather (Charlie Valentine), comes jogging up and briefly talks to Colleen while she's still holding the item in her teeth. After Heather jogs away, Colleen looks embarrassed because she just made a fool of herself in front of her crush. Since Heather jogs by at the same time every day, Colleen vows to look more appealing for her tomorrow. The next day, Colleen is wearing a nice outfit with high heels, waiting for Heather to come jogging by. Colleen then spots Heather and starts heading her way, but Colleen suddenly stumbles and the heel on one of her shoes snaps off. Heather asks if she's okay, and Colleen says she's fine even though she feels embarrassed again. A day later, Colleen is relaxing at home when she gets an unexpected visit from Heather, who wanted to make sure Colleen is okay after the previous day's stumble. Seeing this as another chance, Colleen invites Heather inside. But as they approach the couch, Heather sees that part of Colleen's skirt is caught in her panties! Colleen is embarrassed yet again, confessing that she likes Heather but keeps turning into a walking disaster in front of her. However, it turns out that during each 'embarrassing' incident, Heather was just focused on how much she thinks Colleen is hot! Realizing they're on the same page, they eagerly come together to have sex.
